Holiday Gifts, 2025

Holiday Gifts, 2025

    Filter

      Whether you're shopping for yourself or seeking out a gift for the collector in your life, The Pennysleever has you covered! From hobby supply staples like toploaders and card sleeves to exciting bundles, we've got it all. Take a look at all we have to offer, and save some money on our top quality supplies.

      16 products
      Sale
      Doorbuster #3: 10,000 Regular Card Sleeves, $99
      $ 199.00 $ 99.00 Save $ 100.00
      Sale
      Doorbuster #2: 100 Standard (35 pt) Magnetic Card Holders, $149
      $ 180.00 $ 149.00 Save $ 31.00
      Sale
      Doorbuster #1: 1,000 Standard 35 pt Toploaders, $99
      $ 159.60 $ 99.00 Save $ 60.60
      Sale
      Silicone slab bumper with packaging on a white background
      The Holiday Spirit Bundle
      $ 49.32 $ 42.99 Save $ 6.33
      Color Me Sorted x Foddy Bundle
      $ 29.99
      The Rip Buddy Semi-Rigid Bundle
      $ 49.99
      The Rip Buddy 35 pt Toploader Bundle
      from $ 49.90
      The Rip Buddy Two Color Bundle
      $ 49.99
      The Rip Buddy (Semi-Rigid Card Holder Version)
      $ 21.99
      The Rip Buddy (Toploader Version)
      $ 19.99
      Foddy Multirow Box Divider
      $ 14.99
      Vintage Magnetic Card Holder
      $ 4.49
      Black 9 pocket card collectors album with 'PENNYSLEEVER' logo on a white background
      9 Pocket Premium Album
      $ 19.99
      Stack of four different colored aluminum bumpers for graded cards from The Pennysleever
      Packaged aluminum bumper for PSA graded cards with a card displayed on a white background
      PSA Aluminum Case
      $ 19.99
      Box of blue silicone slab bumpers with a card design on a white background
      PSA Silicone Slab Bumpers (6 count)
      $ 14.99
      Sale
      The True Fan
      $ 118.85 $ 100.00 Save $ 18.85