Real reviews from real collectors
these are really good toploaders. the shipping is lightning fast as well as it only takes 3 to 4 days to get.
these sleeves are exactly what i had hoped for. great quality as always. thats why i keep coming back.
Thank you again for sending these. They are great
Great product, great prices, and fast shipping what more can you ask for!
I love these penny sleeves. One hundred count for a cheap price, and the sleeves are a perfect fit for my sports cards. I would definitely be buying more!
I got two cases for 1951 Topps cards. So far as I can tell, this is the only case custom made for that size card. Lucky for us it’s really high quality and looks great. A perfect way to honor these historic cards. I was so excited to get the cases and place the cards in them and they did not disappoint. Also they shipped during a snow storm and got here really fast.
Great product and very happy with end result.
The sleeves worked perfectly. Thank you!
Terrific product and customer service. Will continue to buy from them in the future.
Absolutely love these sleeves. They're the perfect size to fit all the way into a top loader and still be able to grip the tab easily. Will definitely be buying more of these soon!
Toploaders and Sleeves are too wide and not same size as others. They don't fit in the storage containers I use.
We're so sorry for your poor experience. It seems that you have misunderstood the sizing on our vintage toploaders and sleeves. As indicated both on the package and on the website, each of these products is designed to accommodate larger vintage cards, and thus would be larger than the standard toploaders and sleeves you are used to. We'll review the listing and see if there is anything that can be done to make this clearer.
We'd love to make things right, and will reach out to you privately.
Very happy with everything I purchased. Will definitely do business with them again.
Dear Doug:
We're so pleased to hear you are satisfied with your order. We can't wait to see you back soon!
C
PSA Aluminum Case perfectly crafted absolutely love the company and always buy from them
exactly what i wanted. it arrived super fast and for a very reasonable price.definitly will order again.
The products are top quality. I have replaced other company top loaders with the PennySleever brand!
Thank you so much for the generous review. We're so glad that you are pleased with our supplies!
Fast shipping and great customer service. I have had multiple orders and not one problem.
Amazing product and I will continue to be a repeat buyer thank you so much and happy new year!
Happy 2026 to you as well! We look forward to keeping your cards protected all year round!