Real reviews from real collectors
These are really cool and make your cards really pop!
The magnetic lock pulls out of the plastic housing it sits in. Came like that...didn't want to deal with returning it.
Thanks so much for sharing your experience, and giving us the opportunity to improve. We'll reach out privately to see how we can make this right.
Quick mailing! Hard product to find! Glad you sell it!
Thank you so much for your kind words! We're thrilled to hear you found what you were looking for and appreciated the quick shipping. We do our best to get things in your hands as fast as possible!
I use these, add a label to the tab, and sort cards in BCW shoe boxes...
Thanks so much for sharing this terrific tip; I'm sure this will be helpful to other collectors. We thought there were are a hundred uses for our tabbed card sleeves, but now we realize we short counted! :)
I had some regular penny sleeves but my pre-1960 cards were just a bit too big. Ordered these Vintage Card Sleeves and received them promptly a couple days later. They worked perfect on my '55 Topps Killebrew and a few others I just sent off to SGC for grading.
Hi Bret, we're thrilled to hear the Vintage Card Sleeves fit your pre-1960 cards perfectly! Card sleeves are not a one-size-fits-all endeavour, which is why we are always looking to expand our catalogue. Good luck with your grades on The Killer, and we can't wait to see you again!
Thank you for an easy, pleasant transaction! Everything I purchased was top quality without any issues, you guys are great! Support Small Businesses!
We appreciate the generous review, and will keep working hard to maintain your trust.
Always the best quality card supplies from thepennysleever.com
Thanks so much! We are appreciative of your loyalty, and will keep working hard to keep your trust!
All of the sleeves that I have purchased are perfect.quick delivery
Thank you very much for the great feedback. We're not sure how we can top PERFECT, but we're going to give it a try!
Love em !!!!
Thank you so much for the review! We appreciate you taking the time to share your feelings with other collectors looking for a fun option to protect and display their cards.
It does not fit some of the SGC slabs i have tried. Two of the three so far the sleeves were too small and they ripped apart.
We're sorry to hear that you encountered issues with the Perfect Fit SGC Graded Card Sleeves, and we apologize for the inconvenience it has caused you. These sleeves are designed to fit snugly on standard slabs, so if the slab is for a thicker card, it is possible that the seams will slip. Regardless, we need to do a better job of communicating this, and will work to communicate this more clearly.
We'll be reaching out privately to see what we can do to make this right.
I should have looked into these sooner. Perfect fit for my work out SGC slab covers, also a great team bag for higher volume of cards
Shipped the next day, neat packaging and solid on updates.
I will be bavj for more! Thank you!
Thanks so much for the generous review! We're so glad you like the fit of our SGC sleeves, and that you've found multiple uses for them. We agree that the thicker film we use makes these ideal for storage and shipping of larger groups of cards, and we appreciate you sharing this advice with others.
High quality! Will order again!
Thanks very much for the kind review. We're so glad that you enjoyed the range of Colored Border Toploaders, and can't wait to see you again when you need more!
High quality! Will order again!
We're so glad that you love our colored border toploaders, and appreciate you trying out so many different colors. Can't wait to see you again!
Each toploader is nice n crisp, with a snug grip on cards! Feels very durable along with the colors making each card POP in their own way! If I ever need anymore, I'll def be coming back! (They also write hand written thank you notes 😭)
Thanks so much for the generous, poetic, and detailed review! If your collection is anything like ours, it isn't a question of if, but when, you need more, and when you do, we'll be ready for you!
p.s. We're glad you liked the hand written note. It makes the writer's cramp worth it! 🙂
Each toploader is nice n crisp, with a snug grip on cards! Feels very durable along with the colors making each card POP in their own way! If I ever need anymore, I'll def be coming back! (They also write hand written thank you notes 😭)
Each toploader is nice n crisp, with a snug grip on cards! Feels very durable along with the colors making each card POP in their own way! If I ever need anymore, I'll def be coming back! (They also write hand written thank you notes 😭)
Each toploader is nice n crisp, with a snug grip on cards! Feels very durable along with the colors making each card POP in their own way! If I ever need anymore, I'll def be coming back! (They also write hand written thank you notes 😭)
Each toploader is nice n crisp, with a snug grip on cards! Feels very durable along with the colors making each card POP in their own way! If I ever need anymore, I'll def be coming back! (They also write hand written thank you notes 😭)
Each toploader is nice n crisp, with a snug grip on cards! Feels very durable along with the colors making each card POP in their own way! If I ever need anymore, I'll def be coming back! (They also write hand written thank you notes 😭)
Each toploader is nice n crisp, with a snug grip on cards! Feels very durable along with the colors making each card POP in their own way! If I ever need anymore, I'll def be coming back! (They also write hand written thank you notes 😭)
10/10 Toploaders
Each toploader is nice n crisp, with a snug grip on cards! Feels very durable along with the colors making each card POP in their own way! If I ever need anymore, I'll def be coming back! (They also write hand written thank you notes 😭)
Just received my first order and back to order more !
Thank you so much! Great products, great quality!
The personalized letter inside was a wonderful added touch of top notch customer service!!!
Thank you!!!
Dear Heidi:
Thanks so much for taking the time to write a review. We would have been satisfied with just an A++++ 🙂 We take pride in our products and our service, and appreciate the acknowledgement.
Thanks again, and see you soon!