Real reviews from real collectors

Top quality product and fast shipping. Support this family business putting out great product at competitive prices.

fit the bowman cards of 51 and 52 perfect. love my cards are not moving around.. talked about the 3 vintage sleeves in my latest youtube video.

Thank you for the generous review! Please share the link to your video, so we can all enjoy it. :)

Great for the smaller cards so there not moving around.

love how this fit the bigger cards of the 1950's and fit in 8 slot binder pages

love this for organizing my team sets.

Great product like the thicker sleeves

Thanks so much for taking the time to review our Superior Sleeves. Please let us know what we can do to get from four stars to five... we're never going to be satisfied with a B-! :)

Color frame mags

I grabbed these for my '89 Topps TMNT sticker collection. The cases really make them pop. Great price. Great quality. Thank you!

Hi Brandon! We're so happy to hear the card holders make your stickers stand out. Those pictures look great! The only down side is that any reference to Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles makes me want pizza. Thanks for your kind words and for choosing The Pennysleever!

I ordered BLUE x 5 top loaders you sent me purple ones in a blue package. Please make this right and send blue or refund my money. Have contacted via email and Facebook with no reply.

Let's go over some facts. Your order was placed at 5:51 a.m. on September 28, and shipped out at 9:03 a.m. the same day. You received your order at 12:39 p.m. on October 2, and at 8:13 p.m., after business hours, sent a message to our support email. You followed up at 8:31 p.m with a Facebook message, and upon not receiving a response immediately, you elected to leave a one star review. This is your choice.

Getting back to the product, while we are sorry that you are disappointed in the shade of blue that we use for our Color Frame Colored Border Toploader, we feel that the color is fairly represented in our product images. We take care to make sure that these images are all authentic, unaltered shots of our products, to offer the best representation of the shade; while different devices may present differently, we do everything we can to make sure collectors can see what they are getting. We will reach out privately, during business hours, about your dissatisfaction with the color.

Wonderful experience and great product

Wonderful experience and great product. I will be back.

We're so glad you had a great experience and love the product! Looking forward to your next visit. Thanks for your support, and happy collecting!

Definitely a product I’ll be purchasing again.

We're so glad to hear that the Vintage Magnetic Card Holders are helping you enjoy your collection. We appreciate the kind words, and look forward to seeing you again.

Great quality

Great quality sleeves

Best Top Loaders Ever

Great products as always! These colored top loaders really help my PC cards pop.

We love hearing that our Color Frame toploaders are helping people enjoy their collections more. We're always learning new ways that people use these, but whether it is for color matching teams, organizing collections, or just general appearance, we're happy to be a part of peoples' collecting lives.

Great small business

Great small business. They help me when I need bulk orders and always respond promptly. Shipping is super fast. Always will come here for more.

Hi Jay, thank you so much for your kind words! We're always happy to help, and appreciate you reaching out to us when you need to place a bulk order. We know that the extra step of contacting us directly to arrange a shipment is inconvenient, and appreicate that you keep coming back.

Yes. There are One Touch Holders for Odd Size Vintage

Recently picked up a 1951 Bowman and was curious if anyone made a nice one touch for display as I wasn't going to display the card in a cardsaver or toploader. Did a google search and found the Pennysleever. Not only did they have a one touch for the 51 Bowman, they also had a one touch for my 34 Goudey I have. Purchased both and I couldn't be happier. The price was right. Shipping was prompt and the cards look awesome in the holders. Also, the handwritten thank you note was a plus. This satisfied customer will conduct business with again.

We are very glad that you found us, too! :) We are quite proud of our line of Vintage Magnetic Card Holders, and are continuing to grow the line of sizes that we offer. We feel that as grading becomes more unaffordable, these provide a great way to display, and enjoy, your collection!

Thanks very much for sharing your experience, and we can't wait to see you back!

I love these PINK toploaders! 🩷
they keep all of my cards safe 💗 and they are perfect for shipping out orders from my little shop 💌
love the sweet little note in my orders, too <3 so sorry for not leaving a review sooner… THANK U ♡

Thanks so much for the generous review, and for sharing the (very pink!) picture from your collection. We're so happy to have you as a supporter, and appreciate the kind words. And no need to apologize for not leaving a review sooner... we are here for you, not vice versa! 💗

Great product!

Great product!

Great product

Great product, excellent value price. It was shipped quickly. My one stop shop for card protection.

We appreciate your loyalty! Thank you for your generous review, and we look forward to serving you whenever your cards need protection!

Every thing perfect

Every thing perfect. Thank you.

It'll be hard for us to top perfect (but that won't stop us from trying)!

We appreciate you sharing your experience with others, and look forward to seeing you back soon!

I love your product. Thanks for making my pc look better!

Thanks so much for the kind review, and for sharing the picture of your binder page! A picture really does tell the story, and we are happy that you love our Color Frame Toploaders for your Pokémon cards! 💛💛💛

Fun and functional!

I bought a large variety of colors of these, and it really adds a fun new element to the hobby, picking out a case that will really compliment each card! Iove the purple, and the black and white both look awesome with so many different cards. The only color I wasn't thrilled with was the red, because I wish it was a bit of a deeper/truer red, like what would match the chicago bulls. Instead it seems more red/orange. But overall I am super happy with these cases and the quality seems really nice! They don't seem to scratch too easily which is great. And they're a good snug fit so even paper thin cards don't slide around much. If I need to buy more top loaders in the future, Pennysleever is where I'll go!

Thanks so much for the generous and comprehensive review. We agree that color does add an element of fun (what a novel concept!) to collecting, and are glad that you enjoy our line of Color Frame products. We appreciate the feedback on the red, and are always looking for ways to improve the collector experience.

Very happy with my

Very happy with my purchase

Order arrived quick and they look great! Will be ordering more soon for cyberpunk tcg

Order arrived quick and they look great! Will be ordering more soon for cyberpunk tcg.

Thanks so much for the kind review. We're so glad you love our products, and look forward to seeing you soon!

Top notch

Top notch products and service

Love this company; If you’re still deciding on where to buy your sleeves/toploaders then look no further, this is the place you want to go! Always a great experience, always top quality, I have zero bad things to say. Thanks for everything The Pennysleever, I will always support you!!!

And we have zero bad things to say about you! As folks on eBay say, "⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Buyer!!!"

Thanks so much for the kind words, and we are grateful for your loyalty. We can't wait to see you again!

Why I order these

I bought these for a special set of baseball card I have because of their different size. These top loaders were a very good fit for them.
They are very good quality a well made

Fits just right

With over 40,000 cards in my collection, I have stayed away from the top loaders and use semi rigid card holders instead. They are lighter weight, cost less but still offer the protection I need. I recently ordered semi rigid holders from the Pennysleever and I LOVE them. I've tried other brands but find it difficult to slide the cards into them. The ones from Pennysleever seem to be much easier to load cards into. I will be ordering more in the future.

One more thing. I can't help but rave about a company that takes the time to put a handwritten thank you note in the box with your order. There's something about supporting a small family run business that just seems right.

Many thanks and keep up the good work!

Thank you very much for the expansive review, and for sharing some tips on how to store cards with newer collectors. Semi-rigid card holders are vastly underappreciated, and we are grateful for your sharing your experience with others.

We do appreciate you wanting to support our small family business, but more importantly, we are pleased that you are happy with our products. Can't wait to see you again!

Perfect mag holders

I purchased the magnetic holders for sleeved cards to protect my more valuable ones and was a little skeptical on what to expect with the quality due to the lower price point so i placed a smaller order as a test run. These things are perfect for my needs. I'll be placing a larger order on the next go around.

Thanks so much for the great review! We appreciate your suggestion that we raise our prices to better reflect the quality of our products. 😉

Joking aside, we do our best to honor our motto of Top quality supplies at fair prices. We appreciate you taking the time to share your experience, and can't wait to see you again.

AMAZING PRODUCTS

I just received my first 1955 Bowman magnetic card holder from them and it fits perfectly! Will definitely be shopping here more and love to support a small business!

We're so glad you are happy with our Vintage Magnetic Card Holders, and can't wait to see you again. We think it is important to have vintage supplies that actually fit the products, so collectors can actually enjoy looking at their collections, rather than just storing them in ugly, ill fitting options. We are committed to growing our line of vintage supplies, and are so glad to have you aboard!

Vintage Top Loaders

Looking for vintage top loaders and penny sleeves. Good prices, quality pennies and top loads, slightly bigger than others but I like them. Perfect for the 1956 Topps set that I'm taking out of a binder to protect better. Shipping is normal cost, packaged well and shipped quick. I have already been back for more! God Bless you, your business, family & the USA!!

Thanks very much for the kind words, and we are so glad that you found us. The Pennysleever is committed to providing the widest selection of vintage card supplies on the market, and we are very happy to hear that you have been pleased with our toploaders and sleeves. We appreciate the support, and look forward to seeing you again.

wonderful resource

everything you need to protect your trading card collectibles with great prices, fast shipping, and kind and personalized customer service. a handwritten thank you note accompanied my first order. all my orders will be through the pennysleever from now on!

Thanks so much for the generous review, and we are pleased to hear that we have earned your trust. We enjoy providing the best quality supplies to collectors, and will continue working hard to maintain your trust.

Hard To Find Colored Toploaders

I ordered orange border top loaders for my cards. The usual big sites did not have anyone that carried the orange color. I could not find them in a stand alone pack. I am so glad I found them here. Price was great. Service was fast. Toploaders look great.
I received a hand written thank you card. It shows how much they really care about service and appreciate their customers.
I do not have any hesitations about ordering items in the future.
Thanks!

We're so happy that you are enjoying our orange Color Frame toploaders. We may not be the biggest, but we are working to have the most substantial catalogue of supplies of anybody. We appreciate you taking the time to share your experience, and look forward to seeing you again!

Great service and product

Great first time buy. Will do again

First Order

I just started reviewing a large baseball card collection that's been in storage for 35 years. My 1st order was made on a Monday and arrived in the mail on Wednesday. The sleeves work great. I'll be ordering more soon!

Sounds like you have a daunting (and fun!) task ahead of you. When you find you need more supplies (and you will... there are never enough when you need them!) we'll be here. Thanks for the kind review.

Vintage Card Sleeves

Was happy to find these card sleeves for my 1948-50 & 1951-52 Bowman cards online. I couldn't find them anywhere locally. Quality of the sleeves seems really good. Shipping was super quick which I appreciate. Will definitely buy from this supplier again.

Thanks so much for the kind review. The Pennysleever is dedicated to serving the underappreciated market, and we're so glad that you found us. We hope that you'll keep checking back, as we continue to grow our line of vintage supplies.

Absolutely the Best

Just received another perfect order from The Penny Sleever. I never buy my sports card and TCG supplies from anywhere else.

Thank you!!!!
Joseph

Amazing!!!

I love this company and their card supplies. I found them through Google they popped up as a supply company. Im always weary about new things on the internet as there are so many scams. Their products are amazing I usually get the 36 point mag holders that you can use sleeves with. The prices are very good and the holders are top notch quality. Every order I've gotten a hand written letter thanking me for the purchase. I also reached out to them and asked if they could help with a card I have that is bigger than usual. They didn't have it but responded to me very quickly. I have to say this is the best overall company I have ever dealt with. They have a lifelong customer in me and I am saying up to get a grip of the aluminum graded cases!!! I love supporting other than mega corporations!! Thanks I'll be ordering again soon!!

Thanks so much for the generous review, and the incredible pictures of your collection. We're so happy to hear that everything worked out, and that you trusted Google (this time). We do take pride in our quality products, and appreciate you helping us spread the word. Now that we are old friends, and not strangers on the Internet, we hope you'll feel confident coming back when you need more supplies!

Top tier cases and service

Could not be happier with my experience buying from Pennysleever! The cases look amazing and shipped quickly. Will certainly be buying from them again in the future!

Hi Brandon, thank you for the wonderful review! We are so glad to know that we met your expectations, and look forward to seeing you again when your collection needs protecting!

Chasing rainbows!

Love your products great quality, great price fast shipping. Everyone should shop with confidence knowing their getting a superior product at an affordable price.

Dear Kent:

Thanks for sharing these pictures; it's always a pleasure seeing how collectors use our top quality supplies. Unline the ROY G BIV rainbow, we're looking to expand our color range even further! Maybe not as fast as Topps does with their variations, but we're trying. 🙂

LOVE EM !!!

These toploaders are the best I love the color !!!!

Hi Aki! We're so happy to hear you love the Colored Border Toploaders! Thanks for sharing your great feedback and we hope to see you again soon!

Best top loaders ever

I almost never leave reviews, but these top loaders absolutely deserve one. They're excellent quality, color, crystal clear, and sturdy exactly what I was looking for to keep my cards protected. This has easily been one of my best purchases.
What really made this seller stand out, though, was the handwritten personalized thank you card included with my order. It's such a small gesture, but it made the experience feel personal and showed they genuinely appreciate their customers. Great product, great service, and I'll definitely be ordering from them again. Highly recommend!

Thanks Matty; your feedback is appreciated! As collectors ourselves, we know how important high quality supplies are to enjoying your colletion, and we are committed to not selling anything that we wouldn't use in our own collection. It means a lot to us that you took the time to share your experience with others, and we look forward to seeing you again soon!

Bowman vintage sleeves

Ordered '48 - '50 Bowman sleeves and '51 - '52 Bowman sleeves. Good condition. Good webpage. Fast shipping also.
Very well done transaction!
Thank you!!

Hi Lee, we're thrilled to hear you had a great experience. We're focused on providing as many options to vintage sports card collectors that we can. We rely on feedback like yours to spread the word, so thank you for taking the time to share!

All-Star Quality Product

Thank you PennySleever for the new supplies for my collection! I ordered some 35 pt magnetic holders, a top loader bundle and a 180 pt mag holder for this sweet Hank RC Logo Medallion card (didn’t know 180pt was a thing until I needed it). Not only can you see the difference in their products, you can FEEL the difference. Quality is an understatement. Safe to say any leftover supplies I have from other companies will be used for shipping. Y'all give them a look, you
won't be disappointed!

Thank you for the generous feedback, and for sharing your experience with others. We do carry a full range of sizes of both toploaders and sleeves, and we're always happy when a collector finds the solution they need. We are glad that you appreciate the quality of our products-- we won't sell anything we would not personally use! Thank you again, and we look forward to your next visit.

Great customer service!!!

I collect early comic strips and related paper items including post cards from the “Golden Era” with designs by Outcault, Dirks, Swinnerton and so on. I’ve collected faster than I’ve protected. So I’m really glad to find this online shop. The prices are super low, the shipping is immediate, and the customer service sets it apart from pretty much anyone else! Thank you and I’ll be back!

Hi Jessie, thank you so much for your wonderful review! We're thrilled to hear you’re happy with our service! We do take pride in making sure collectors of all stripes get their supplies as fast as they can. If that means it takes us a couple of weeks to reply to reviews, so be it! 😛 We appreciate you!

Aluminum cases are fantastic!

Not only do they protect your collection, the colored borders pair perfectly with the proper card to make the collection really pop!!! Well worth the money. Great product!

Hi Michael, thank you for your wonderful review! We're thrilled to hear that you love our Aluminum Cases for PSA Graded Cards. With eleven colors, it is sometimes hard to choose, and we're glad to hear that you were able to pair them up well. Thanks very much, and we look forward to seeing you again!

Amazing product

After opening and putting a few cards in, I alternated between anger that it took Google so long to put this front and center in my many searches for card storage and joy at FINALLY finding products (especially penny sleeves and one-touch cases) that fit my old, odd shaped cards. Oh, and I grabbed their regular top loaders just to check them out - they're clearer than my UltraPro ones. If you have vintage cards and, like me, you prefer raw, I've never found anything remotely close to this. Even more crazy - these are literally cheaper than the same product by UltraPro! You have made a future repeat customer for sure. Thank you for so capably filling a missing niche.

Thanks so much for sharing your experience! While we lack the ability to control Google, we're psyched that you found us! We do take pride in offering more options for vintage collectors, and we plan to keep adding more sizes.

As for the pricing, we do strive to provide the best quality products at great prices, and we're glad to hear that we stack up favorably to leading brands. However, quality comes first!

Let customers speak for us