Best Sellers

Best Sellers

    Filter
      89 products
      A single super clear, high quality 180pt magnetic card holder from The Pennysleever.
      A single super clear, high quality side view of 180pt magnetic card holder from The Pennysleever.
      180 pt Magnetic Card Holder
      from $ 2.99
      A single pack of crystal clear, high quality 55pt magnetic card holder from The Pennysleever.
      45 degree angled view of a crystal clear 55 point magnetic card holder from The Pennysleever.
      55 pt Magnetic Card Holder
      from $ 2.49
      A pack of 25 count high quality vintage toploaders from The Pennysleever that holds vintage-sized cards of up to 2⁵⁄₈'' x 3¹⁵⁄₁₆''.
      A pack of 25 count vintage card sleeves from The Pennysleever with a visible brand label on a white background
      Vintage Toploader (25 count)
      $ 6.49
      A pack of 25 count high quality mini/tobacco-sized T206 toploaders from The Pennysleever that holds mini/tobacco-sized cards of up to 1⁷⁄₁₆'' x 2⁵⁄₈'', made with top quality PVC for a smooth card insert.
      A side by side sample of high quality mini/tobacco-sized T206 toploaders from The Pennysleever that holds mini/tobacco-sized cards of up to 1⁷⁄₁₆'' x 2⁵⁄₈'', made with top quality PVC for a smooth card insert.
      Tobacco-sized Toploader (25 count)
      $ 5.79
      A single super clear, high quality 100pt magnetic card holder from The Pennysleever.
      A super clear, high quality The Pennysleever's 100 point magnetic card holder at a 45 degree angle against a white background.
      100 pt Magnetic Card Holder
      from $ 2.99
      A pack of 100 count high quality vintage card sleeves for 1951-52 Bowman vintage cards from The Pennysleever, fits up to 2¹⁄₁₆'' x 3¹⁄₈'' sized cards.
      A pack of 100 count high quality vintage card sleeves for 1951-52 Bowman vintage cards, with custom card insert from The Pennysleever, fits up to 2¹⁄₁₆'' x 3¹⁄₈'' sized cards.
      Vintage Card Sleeves 1951-52 Bowman (100 count)
      from $ 2.79
      A single super clear, high quality 75pt magnetic card holder from The Pennysleever.
      Front view of a super clear, high quality 75 point magnetic card holder with a custom card insert from The Pennysleever.
      75 pt Magnetic Card Holder
      from $ 2.99
      A pack of 10 count high quality and super clear 260pt Toploaders from The Pennysleever, for very thick trading cards, thick patch cards, booklet-style cards, premium inserts, and memorabilia-style cards.
      Vintage-style baseball card protected in a high quality, super clear 260pt toploader from The Pennyleever.
      260 pt Toploader (10 count)
      $ 5.29
      A pack of 100 count high quality multi-purpose graded sleeves from The Pennysleever, designed to fits slabs from all major grading companies, made with clear non-PVC film, and 60 micron film thickness.
      A sample of high quality multi-purpose graded sleeve from The Pennysleever, designed to fits slabs from all major grading companies, made with clear non-PVC film, and 60 micron film thickness.
      Resealable Graded Card Sleeves (100 count)
      from $ 4.99
      A single super clear, high quality 260pt magnetic card holder from The Pennysleever.
      Front view of a 260 point magnetic card holder with a custom card insert on display from The Pennysleever.
      260 pt Magnetic Card Holder
      from $ 3.49
      A single super clear, high quality 360pt magnetic card holder from The Pennysleever.
      Close-up of the right corner of a 360 point magnetic card holder against a white backdrop.
      360 pt Magnetic Card Holder
      from $ 3.49
      A black color-9 pocket premium binder card collectors album with 'The Pennysleever' embossed logo on a white background.
      Black zippered suede album for sleeved cards with a grid of compartments on a white background
      9 Pocket Premium Sleeve Album
      $ 21.99
      Two packages of The Pennysleever 'Exquisite Fit Inner Sleeves' (100 count) Top-Loading and Side-Loading with colorful labels on a white background.
      A pack of The Pennysleever 'Exquisite Fit Inner Sleeves' Top-Loading with colorful labels on a white background.
      Pokémon/TCG Exquisite Fit Inner Sleeves (100 count)
      $ 1.99
      A pack of 100 count high quality vintage card sleeves for 1948-50 Bowman vintage cards from The Pennysleever, fits up to 2¹⁄₁₆'' x 2¹⁄₂'' sized cards.
      A pack of 100 count high quality vintage card sleeves for 1948-50 Bowman vintage cards, with custom card insert from The Pennysleever, fits up to 2¹⁄₁₆'' x 2¹⁄₂'' sized cards.
      Vintage Card Sleeves 1948-50 Bowman (100 count)
      from $ 2.79
      A pack of 100 count high quality tabbed card sleeves that fits standard-sized 35 pt cards, made with clear non-PVC film and fit easily into toploaders or semi-rigid holders for extra protection from The Pennysleever.
      A sample of high quality tabbed card sleeve with custom card insert that fits standard-sized 35 pt cards, made with clear non-PVC film and fit easily into toploaders or semi-rigid holders for extra protection from The Pennysleever.
      Tabbed Card Sleeves (100 count)
      from $ 2.79
      A pack of super clear, high quality 100 count postcard-sized sleeves by The Pennysleever that holds postcards up to 3¹¹⁄₁₆'' x 5³⁄₄''.
      Sample of super clear, high quality postcard-sized sleeves by The Pennysleever that holds postcards up to 3¹¹⁄₁₆'' x 5³⁄₄''.
      Postcard Sized Sleeves (100 count)
      from $ 2.79
      A pack of 5 count high quality and super clear 360pt Toploaders from The Pennysleever, for ultra thick trading cards, thick patch cards, booklet-style cards, premium inserts, and memorabilia-style cards.
      A stack of super clear 360pt toploaders for thick premium trading cards from The Pennysleever.
      360 pt Toploader (5 count)
      $ 4.49
      A pack of 100 count high quality vintage card sleeves for Goudey & Leaf vintage cards from The Pennysleever, fits up to 2³⁄₈'' x 2⁷⁄₈'' sized cards.
      A sample of high quality vintage card sleeves for Goudey & Leaf vintage cards with custom card insert from The Pennysleever, fits up to 2³⁄₈'' x 2⁷⁄₈'' sized cards.
      Vintage Card Sleeves Goudey & Leaf (100 count)
      from $ 2.79
      A pack of 100 count high quality card sleeves for tall cards from The Pennysleever that holds cards of up to 2⁵⁄₈'' x 4¹³⁄₁₆''.
      A sample of high quality card sleeves for tall cards from The Pennysleever that holds cards of up to 2⁵⁄₈'' x 4¹³⁄₁₆''.
      Card Sleeves for Tall Cards (100 count)
      from $ 2.79
      An image of the Pennysleever's Magnetic Card Holder for Packs, designed to hold booster packs for Pokémon, Magic the Gathering, or other TCGs, and hold standard sized sports card packs of 2½" x 3 ½" as well. Providing stylish UV protection, these magnetic card holders are ideal for storage or display. With a strong gold magnet, it'll keep your packs safe and sound.
      The Pennysleever magnetic card holder for packs in a single packaging on a white background.
      Magnetic Card Holder for Packs
      $ 4.99
      A pack of 50 count semi-rigid card holder sized #2 that holds cards of up to 3'' x 4¹⁄₂'' for a smooth insert and super high clarity and quality from The Pennysleever on a white background.
      A stack sample of semi-rigid card holder sized #2 that holds cards of up to 3'' x 4¹⁄₂'' for a smooth insert and super high clarity and quality from The Pennysleever on a white background.
      Semi-Rigid Card Holder #2 (3'' x 4¹⁄₂'') (50 count)
      from $ 6.99
      A pack of 50 semi-rigid card holders sized #4 that holds cards of up to 4¹⁄₂'' x 7¹⁄₈'' for a smooth insert and super high clarity and quality from The Pennysleever on a white background.
      Sample of a semi-rigid card holder sized #4 that holds card of up to 4¹⁄₂'' x 7¹⁄₈'' from The Pennysleever on a white background.
      Semi-Rigid Card Holder #4 (4¹⁄₂'' x 7¹⁄₈'') (50 count)
      from $ 14.99
      A pack of high quality, ultra clear 25 count postcard-sized toploaders and documents from The Pennysleever that holds postcards up to 5⅞" x 3¾".
      Sample of high quality, ultra clear postcard-sized toploaders and documents from The Pennysleever that holds postcards up to 5⅞" x 3¾".
      Postcard Sized Toploaders (25 count)
      $ 12.99
      A pack of 100 count high quality vintage card sleeves for 1939-41 Play Ball vintage cards from The Pennysleever, fits up to 2¹⁄₂'' x 3¹⁄₈'' sized cards.
      A sample of high quality vintage card sleeves for 1939-41 Play Ball vintage cards with custom card insert from The Pennysleever, fits up to 2¹⁄₂'' x 3¹⁄₈'' sized cards.
      Vintage Card Sleeves 1939-41 Play Ball (100 count)
      from $ 2.79
      The Rip Buddy Toploader Version in black, blue, red, and white
      Blue and red Rip Buddy Toploader Version card sorting accessories
      The Rip Buddy (Toploader Version)
      $ 21.99
      A pack of 100 count high quality vintage card sleeves for 1951 Topps vintage cards from The Pennysleever, fits up to 2'' x 2⁵⁄₈'' sized cards.
      The Pennysleever pack of vintage 1951 Topps card sleeves.
      Vintage Card Sleeves 1951 Topps (100 count)
      from $ 2.79
      A single black colored 9 pocket value album, fits 360 sleeved cards with 'The Pennysleever' logo on a white background.
      Collection of sample custom trading cards in a display case of a 9 pocket value album for 360 cards on a white background.
      9 Pocket Value Album
      $ 13.99
      A pack of 25 count high quality, standard 35 pt size Rookie Toploaders from The Pennysleever, for most traditional sports cards and standard trading cards, made from clear virgin PVC for strong clarity and visibility.
      A sample of high quality, standard 35 pt size Rookie Toploaders from The Pennysleever, for most traditional sports cards and standard trading cards, made from clear virgin PVC.
      35 pt Rookie Card Toploader (25 count)
      $ 6.49

      These are the products other collectors are buying.