The Pennysleever 100% Satisfaction Guarantee

We at The Pennysleever are proud of the high quality of all our products, and we stand behind everything we sell. If you have an issue, we want to make it right.

Our Satisfaction Guarantee ensures that if you are not completely satisfied with your purchase, you may request a full refund within 14 days of the original purchase date.

Simply reach out to us via our customer service email, info@thepennysleever.com, and include your order number, product, and a summary of your issue. Once we confirm your details, simply return your product to our warehouse. Refunds will be processed to the original payment method within 7-10 business days upon receipt of the returned item.

This guarantee is limited to one return per customer, and does not apply to any damaged or defective products (see our policy on defective products).

Protects my SGC graded cards and looks great as well!

Protects my SGC graded cards and looks great as well! Thanks

Great holder

Great holder. Quality built.

Impeccable customer service and great products!!

Impeccable customer service and great products!! Well packaged and arrived fast!! Excellent quality too!!

The best supplies and service! Thank

The best supplies and service! Thank you

Wow! Compliments don't come much better than that! We are grateful for your review and the photo as well.

Excellent product! I will continue to use

Excellent product! I will continue to use these!

Quick ship, friendly, high quality

Quick shipping, friendly note, and great toploaders!

Thank you for the terrific review, and we are glad that you appreciate the note. We really appreciate the opportunity to enhance your collecting life.

Same/better quality, half the price of others.

I use 260 pt toploaders to ship small card lots to my customers (typically 10-15 cards). So, naturally, I need to be cost conscious. These are excellent quality toploaders and less than 50% of the cost of BCW and Ultra Pro (about $0.79 each vs. $0.35 each). These Pennysleever toploaders might actually be better quality than BCW and Ultra Pro. Typically, with BCW and Ultra Pro 260 pt toploaders (of which I've used thousands), the front and back toploaders become compressed and lose their form. These toploaders don't seem to experience that issue, which is amazing. Will definitely order from again.

Thanks for sharing your experience with our supplies. We are very glad that you recognized our quality, which we are very proud of. The savings is just the icing on the cake!

Top loaders are excellent

It’s very difficult to find top loaders that accommodate the large size of vintage cards. This is particularly true when it comes to cards from the 1950s. These are sturdy and easy to use. Vintage sleeves, if used with your cards fit easily into the vintage top loaders. The only concern thereafter is if you plan to display the cards, you will need to find a binder that will accommodate the larger size.

Thanks very much for the generous feedback! We are happy to be filling a void for collectors of vintage cards. We appreciate the suggestion about a binder that will accommodate these toploaders, and hope to introduce one in the not too distant future.

Excellent sleeves for vintage

As a vintage collector, I’m always looking for resources tailored to the Need. Cards easily fit into these vintage sleeves without hassle and concern for damage. Really appreciate the offer offering of this product!

Great quality

Great quality, thank you. Will buy again.

Great value

Great value. Great quality.

Always quality products and for prices cheaper than the big names

Always quality products and for prices cheaper than the big names. Always super happy with my order.

Nice product

Looks sharp

These SGC graded sleeve protectors are the best thing I've ever purchased

These SGC graded sleeve protectors are the best thing I've ever purchased. They fit the cards great!!

Dear Josh:

Thanks so much for the high praise. We'll do our best to keep living up to this standard, and look forward to seeing you again soon.

Exactly What I Hoped For

Recently, Ultra Pro cheapened out on their premium sleeves and they're minimally different than the basic ones. I ordered three packs of these from The Pennysleever and they are exactly what I hoped for. Much thicker than basic sleeves and are perfect for the cards I want to keep, but not put into semi-rigids. These will really help in my organizing and downsizing.

Thanks so much for the generous review, and we're so happy to hear that you are pleased with our quality. We'll keep on working hard to live up to the high standards you set for us!

BEST RESEALABLE TOP LOADER BAGS

I HAD RUN OUT OF MY USUAL SUPPLIES AND ORDERED FROM THIS COMPANY! I COULDN'T WAIT FOR MY REORDER OF PENNY SLEEVER BAGS! THE FEEL, TOUCH AND SEAL IS MUCH MORE FITTING AND ENABLES ME TO LOAD MY CARDS FASTER AND WITH BETTER APPEARANCE.

Welcome addition to the hobby

These vintage magnetic card holders are a welcome addition to the hobby. I have a few vintage cards from the 1950's that I collected before grading was a thing, and struggled to find a good holder for them. These Pennysleever magnetic holders are just what I needed. Now I can nicely display and protect my '51 Bowman, '55 Topps, and '56 Topps Ted Williams cards. I asked about the possibility of these types of holders in the past. Thank you, Pennysleever, for making them a reality.

Thanks for the great feedback! We're so happy that we are able to fill a gap for vintage collectors, and hope that we can keep expanding the list of options available. We appreciate you making us a part of your collecting life.

These sleeves are just as advertised

These sleeves are just as advertised. They perfectly fit SGC slabs. Other brands I've tried are too loose with extra space on the sides. The plastic used in these sleeves is thicker and sturdier than other options on the market. Despite the improved quality, these are still much cheaper than their competitors.

Made the recent decision to switch my grading semi-rigids to The PennySleever and couldn’t be happier. They’re top notch quality with nice flexibility so your cards slide in smoothly. They’re priced competitively with the mass made brands and given the choice, supporting a small business makes sense - especially when they take the time to thank you personally with your order!

Thank you, The PennySleever! Cheers!

Excellent Quality!! Will be coming back for

Excellent Quality!! Will be coming back for more!! Thank you!

As usual - Great product and quick

As usual - Great product and quick delivery!!!

Super fast delivery of an outstanding product at a great price

Super fast delivery of an outstanding product at a great price.

Resealable Bags for Toploaders (100 count)

Love these bags for my 55 pt toploaders; snug, but not too tight. Protecting my archived cards, and storing in 2-row boxes was never easier. Many thanks to The Pennysleever - another great product!

We are so glad that our bags fit your collecting needs. As collectors ourselves, we appreciate that storage is an important part of hobby life, and we are flattered to be a part of yours. Thanks so much!

Great Product

Great Product and great company!

Let customers speak for us