The Pennysleever 100% Satisfaction Guarantee

We at The Pennysleever are proud of the high quality of all our products, and we stand behind everything we sell. If you have an issue, we want to make it right.

Our Satisfaction Guarantee ensures that if you are not completely satisfied with your purchase, you may request a full refund within 14 days of the original purchase date.

Simply reach out to us via our customer service email, info@thepennysleever.com, and include your order number, product, and a summary of your issue. Once we confirm your details, simply return your product to our warehouse. Refunds will be processed to the original payment method within 7-10 business days upon receipt of the returned item.

This guarantee is limited to one return per customer, and does not apply to any damaged or defective products (see our policy on defective products).

Great Product

Great Product and great company!

Super responsive and helped resolved my issue efficiently. My very first Toploaders and Sleeves since I just got into collecting. Would definitely come back for more in the future.

Love this product!! Quick shipping and nicely priced with most sizes needed for tobacco, cigarette and vintage trading cards!! Highly recommend this company

Great for card transport!

I'm always taking cards to my local LGS, and I'm in a constant struggle to figure out what to bring the cards in. The struggle is over!

These larger magnetic holders are great for carrying a few cards for transport. The magnet is super strong, so no worries about cards falling out. I could even imagine using these to hold things like token cards for game play. Overall, such an amazing product!

Absolutely rock solid magnetic holder!

An amazing magnetic case that's absolutely rock solid and incredibly affordable. I love that they come in a larger bulk package of 25 holders, and I can't wait to pick up some more for my big hits!

Best way to go with sleeves

For us weird guys that like to dodge the corners and not hurt our priceless cards these are perfect. Great sleeves crystal clear and the corner cutouts give peace of mind when handling, these are a no brainer for the price. Thank you

Just Perfect

These are the only mag holder i am using hence forth love em! Light and super clear clarity they really make the card shine. Love em.

The product and the service are both off the charts

The product and the service are both off the charts. This will not be ny last order!! A family owned small business I can support again and again!!

Thank you for taking the time to share a review. We are incredibly grateful for the support, and look forward to your next order.

Resealable bags for toploaders

Best thing ever. I have lots of cards in toploaders. I have bought 11 100 count bags so far. They help protect my cards and are very clear. Makes it easy to see your cards. Best card supplies in the business.

Thanks so much for the review, and we are super glad to hear that you love the toploader bags. We'll keep working hard to maintain your trust. Happy collecting!

Love the product

BEST IN CLASS

These are the only one touches i buy now they are so clear and love how they display. Get em!!!

THESE ARE THE SLEEVES YOU ARE LOOKING FOR

I have tried countless products and I am blown away with how good these sleeves are, not only do they fit SGC slabs snug and tight they are thick and strong with perfect clarity. Look how good my 56’ Hammer looks in em! Just quality product all around. Buying more real soon.

Thanks very much for the kind words and the generous review. We'd like to say that our SGC graded card sleeves are the difference maker, but the card itself does a lot of the heavy lifting. ;)

THE BEST IN THE MARKET

I have tried countless supplies and listen to me when I say these are the BEST sleeves. There are others that fit snug but not as snug as these and those others easily tear if you put any tension on the edges somehow these things are rock solid and so clear I LOVE THEM AND HIGHLY RECOMMEND. Look how pretty they sit on my 56’ Al Kaline 👌

My now go-to brand

My now go-to brand. Highly recommended.

Always first go-to for for sportcard supplies

Always first go-to for for sportcard supplies. Word of mouth goes a long way. Keep it up Pennysleever!

Thanks so much, and you are right-- word of mouth matters a lot to us. That's why we are so happy to hear from you, and are so pleased that you are willing to share your thoughts with others. We look forward to your next order.

Nothing else is going to compare now!

I found The Pennysleever during a local poke con I was at and they were the nicest! They are really passionate about their products and had a ton of info on the sizes and products based on what I was looking for. The exquisite fit penny sleeves and toploaders are all great quality. No rough cut edges, clear plastic, and the color versions look really nice in my binders. Really impressed and I’m going to be a repeat customer for sure!

Great quality sleeves made a great gift for my card collecting brother

Great quality sleeves made a great gift for my card collecting brother.

The holders are not bent like ULTRA PRO

The holders are not bent like ULTRA PRO. No sratches and no rough edges. Pennysleeves is a 5 stsr product! Thanks. I will reorder when ready.

Thanks very much for your kind review. We are proud of the quality of our products, and it means a lot to us when we hear that collectors love them as well.

My fourth, and certainly not last, perfect order.

After several orders from The Pennysleever I've come to the conclusion that these are the BEST supplies available. The inner sleeves fit perfectly, load onto my cards without damaging them,have a clear look without 'pour swirles' from lesser plastics.

Thank you as always for the thoughtful review. It is very satisfying to know that we are helping collectors enjoy their collections, and we'll keep working hard to offer the best supplies we can.

The Best Brand for Hobby Products.

By far the best quality sleeves and top loaders I have ever used!

Incredible.

The Best. Don't change a thing, and please make more sizes for Card saver 1, 2, 4 and SGC and PSA post card size and even oversize cases in the same quality and thickness. Couldn't be happier with these.

Perfect

My cards look great. Just what I was looking for.

Thank you so much for the five star review, and for sharing the photo as well. As collectors ourselves, we love seeing our supplies out in the wild!

Awesome product!

These pair perfectly with the top loaders. So far I’ve used them with the 35 points. They help keep the top loaders from getting scratched up of course, but also provide a satisfying reassurance of cards not sliding out.

Thanks so much for the generous and detailed review. We are so happy to hear that you've been pleased with our supplies, and always appreciate people taking the time to share their experience with others.

These are awesome! So easy to get card in without damaging the edges and corners because of the cut corner. I’ll definitely be using these and buying more in the future.

Save money right now!

Let customers speak for us