Skip to content
Free Shipping 🚚On Orders $59 and Up
🛒 SHOP BUNDLES AND SAVE 🛒Shop all bundles 
4.96 star rating ⭐Here's what collectors think
  • Shop
    • Toploaders
    • Magnetic Card Holders
    • Card Sleeves, Semi-Rigid Card Holders, Team Bags
    • Bundles & Specials
    • Gift Cards
    • New Arrivals
    • Vintage Shop
    • Pokémon and TCG Shop
    • Accessories
    • Valued Partner Products
  • Card Shows
  • All About Supplies
    • About
    • FAQ
    • Contact
    • News
    • Media
    • The Pennysleever 100% Satisfaction Guarantee
  • account Log in
  • instagram Instagram
  • Facebook
  • YouTube
  • X
Cart
Subtotal
$ 0.00
Shipping, taxes, and discount codes calculated at checkout.
  •  
  •  
  •  
Your cart is currently empty.
  • instagram Instagram
  • Facebook
  • YouTube
  • X
The Pennysleever
  • Shop
    • Toploaders
    • Magnetic Card Holders
    • Card Sleeves, Semi-Rigid Card Holders, Team Bags
    • Bundles & Specials
    • Gift Cards
    • New Arrivals
    • Vintage Shop
    • Pokémon and TCG Shop
    • Accessories
    • Valued Partner Products
  • Card Shows
  • All About Supplies
  • About The Pennysleever
    • About
    • FAQ
    • Contact
    • News
    • Media
    • The Pennysleever 100% Satisfaction Guarantee
account Log in
icon-search Search icon-bag-minimalCart
Home /

Card Shows

Pay It Forward Card Show, Leominster MA, October 20
Oct 15, 2024
Pay It Forward Card Show, Leominster MA, October 20
413 Card Show, Chicopee MA, October 13
Sep 20, 2024
413 Card Show, Chicopee MA, October 13
Central Mass Cards & Collectibles Show, Jefferson MA, October 12
Sep 20, 2024
Central Mass Cards & Collectibles Show, Jefferson MA, October 12
Emerald Square Mall, North Attleboro MA, October 5 and 6
Sep 20, 2024
Emerald Square Mall, North Attleboro MA, October 5 and 6
enVision Hotel, Mansfield MA, September 29
Sep 20, 2024
enVision Hotel, Mansfield MA, September 29
Pay It Forward Card Show, September 15
Sep 02, 2024
Pay It Forward Card Show, September 15
Capital Region Card Show, September 14
Sep 02, 2024
Capital Region Card Show, September 14
Aug 27, 2024
Solomon Pond Mall, Marlborough MA, September 7
The Best Flippin' Card Show at Polar Park
Aug 20, 2024
The Best Flippin' Card Show at Polar Park
Albany Sports Card Show, August 18
card show ·Aug 16, 2024
Albany Sports Card Show, August 18
Jul 30, 2024
How do you use your Pennysleever supplies?
The most summer-y card ever?
May 31, 2024
The most summer-y card ever?
Previous 1 … 3 4 5

You may also like

View all
A pack of 100 count standard card sleeves from The Pennysleever for a smooth insert, super high clarity and high quality card protection supplies.
A pack of super clear, high quality 100 count standard card sleeves from The Pennysleever.
Regular Card Sleeves (100 count)
from $ 1.99
Collection of 35 pt color-bordered Toploaders Color Frame series consist of black, white, blue, red, yellow, and light green Toploaders with 'The Pennysleever' branding on a white background.
A pack of 25 count high quality black colored-border toploaders from The Pennysleever for a smooth card insert.
35 pt Colored Border Toploader (25 count)
$ 5.99
A pack of 25 count high quality and super clear standard 35pt rigid Toploaders from The Pennysleever.
Collection of custom baseball vintage-style trading cards with a box of 25count standard 35pt rigid toploaders from The Pennysleever brand.
35 pt Toploader (25 count)
$ 5.49
A box of a 200 count high quality Toploaders and 200 count Sleeves value pack combination from The Pennysleever.
A box of a 200 count super clear, high quality Toploaders and 200 count Sleeves value pack combination from The Pennysleever.
35 pt Toploader (200 count) with Sleeves COMBO Packs
$ 35.99
The Pennysleever

Shop

  • Toploaders
  • Magnetic Card Holders
  • Card Sleeves, Semi-Rigid Card Holders & Team Bags
  • Bundles & Specials
  • Vintage Shop
  • Pokémon and TCG Shop
  • Accessories
  • Gift Cards

ABOUT

  • About us
  • Contact
  • FAQ

POLICY

  • Privacy Policy
  • Refund Policy
  • Shipping Policy

SUBSCRIBE TO OUR NEWSLETTER

Be the first to know about our biggest and best sales. We love reaching out and sharing, so join our mailing list.

  • instagram Instagram
  • Facebook
  • YouTube
  • X
  • Amazon
  • American Express
  • Apple Pay
  • Diners Club
  • Discover
  • Google Pay
  • Mastercard
  • PayPal
  • Shop Pay
  • Visa

© 2026 The Pennysleever LLC

Powered by Shopify

504
Verified Reviews
Card Shows
★ Reviews

Let customers speak for us

538 reviews
Write a review
98%
(527)
1%
(3)
0%
(2)
1%
(4)
0%
(2)
504
48
J
360 pt Toploader (5 count)
James P. (United States)
Quality of the top loaders was great

Quality of the top loaders was great. They were just too big for the relic card I needed and since I would have to pay to ship back I will just hod on to them instead of eating that cost. I will keep that in mind if I order again.

R
35 pt Colored Border Toploader (25 count)
Rene

Amazing thank you very much

N
Semi-Rigid Card Holder #1 (3⁵⁄₁₆'' x 4⁷⁄₈'') (50 count)
Nicholas

They are great quality and arrived quickly! They’re perfectly sized, too

E
PSA/CGC Aluminum Case
Elon

Beautiful and quality product

G
35 pt Colored Border Toploader (25 count)
Greg P.

Love them. Thank you. Fast shipping.

123